旅行包袋使用痛点征集与设计提问
What do you actually hate about the bags you use for travel?
楼主在印度筹备旅行包品牌,征集用户对现有包袋的不满,要求具体痛点而非泛泛推荐。评论者提出侧面取放笔记本、隐藏挂载点、可收纳可拆卸防雨罩、快速取放口袋等需求,并报告CTB26满载时舒适性不足、Evergoods背负系统不适合全天负重。
讨论分析
本次快照保存 19 条评论,已处理 19 条有效评论。 不代表完整评论或独立用户数。已删除或自动评论不参与分析。
导读依据
主帖
I’m working on a new travel bag brand in India and before I finalize any products, I want to understand what people actually find annoying about the bags they already own.定位到正文 ↓u/ducmite
My first bag with laptop compartment in the side was Timbuk2 HAL about 15 years ago.定位到评论 ↓关键发现
ducmite 使用 Timbuk2 HAL 约15年,喜欢侧面取放笔记本电脑隔层,认为在包侧放时长椅上可不开主仓取放;现用 CTB26 延续此设计。
查看依据(1 处)
u/ducmite
My first bag with laptop compartment in the side was Timbuk2 HAL about 15 years ago. It is a brilliant idea, if you lift bag next to you on a bench sideways then you can access laptop compartment and small items without opening the whole cargo pocket. My current go to bag is CTB26 with the same idea even more refined.定位到评论 ↓moksori 在热带潮湿国家通勤,指出背包肩带无衬垫勒肩、背部出汗、不能自立、笔记本隔层保护不足、缺乏收纳面板、无外部侧袋、不防水防污、太大笨重等问题;喜欢内置可拆卸防雨罩(U Elements 有),希望尺寸为个人物品大小。
查看依据(2 处)
u/moksori
Uncomfortable/unpadded straps that dig in to my shoulders - Sweaty back during commute in a tropical humid country - Doesn't stand up on its own, so it's difficult to put down near my desk. I need it to be stiff/hold its shape - Laptop compartment too unprotected. I would prefer false bottom/corner guards - Lack of organizers/admin panel. I find big empty compartments too unwieldy. I would prefer interior side pockets for small items, a strap/loop for attaching my keys, IDs, space for chargers/connectors/flash drives/pens - Lack of exterior expandable side pockets. I have a foldable umbrella and a regular sized water tumbler that I regularly need to be accessible. - Non-water/stain resistant materials - Too big and bulky. Size-wise, I would prefer personal item size for air travel.定位到评论 ↓u/moksori
Favorite feature I wish other bags had: built in/removable raincover. My beat up U Elements had one.定位到评论 ↓OJGThree 希望快速取放口袋(QAP)真正快速且不受主仓装载影响;认为拉链上的Aquaguard是没用的高级功能;希望Smart Alec顶部翻盖整合QAP。
查看依据(3 处)
u/OJGThree
Feature I wish more bags had: QAP that fulfills the "Q" part and doesn't get limited by how much is in the main compartment定位到评论 ↓u/OJGThree
Bag specific: would love if a QAP was incorporated into the top flap on the Smart Alec, just doesn't feel good trying to use the side pockets for that定位到评论 ↓Jorge-I-Figueroa 在京都、伏见稻荷、金阁寺、岚山全天携带CTB26,装笔记本电脑等,背部被勒出印子,认为Evergoods背负系统不适合;MPL22也不够舒适。
查看依据(1 处)
u/Jorge-I-Figueroa
They look nice, ctb26 carries a ton, but I took mine all day, laptop and all in Kyoto, Fushimi inari, kinkaku ji, bought some sukajan , arashiyama and my back was marked, the evergoods harness is mot made for that, i also have a mpl22 and not even that is that comfortable (this one is great for throwing thing in quickly)定位到评论 ↓ducmite 认为CTB26舒适性取决于背长,肩带收紧时很好,太松时底端搁下背部,重载可能勒入;见过有人拆背部结构板可能有帮助。
查看依据(1 处)
u/ducmite
I think it depends on how tall back user has. If I have my CTB26 straps tight it is great but I can tell when shoulder straps are too loose, the bottom end rests on my lower back and I feel with a heavy load it could really dig in and be uncomfortable. I've seen people mention that removing the structural sheet in the back would help.定位到评论 ↓适用条件与未解决问题
评论者多为个人体验,未提供具体负重数值、包袋尺寸或长期使用后的质量数据。
查看依据(1 处)
关于CTB26舒适性的讨论未涉及具体重量阈值,仅描述主观感受。
查看依据(1 处)
展开分批摘录(12 条)
个人经历
ducmite 使用 Timbuk2 HAL 约15年,喜欢侧面取放笔记本电脑隔层,认为在包侧放时长椅上可不开主仓取放;现用 CTB26 延续此设计。
查看依据(1 处)
u/ducmite
My first bag with laptop compartment in the side was Timbuk2 HAL about 15 years ago. It is a brilliant idea, if you lift bag next to you on a bench sideways then you can access laptop compartment and small items without opening the whole cargo pocket. My current go to bag is CTB26 with the same idea even more refined.定位到评论 ↓具体建议
ducmite 建议在包底部增加类似MOLLE的挂载点,用于固定厚夹克、毯子、额外包等,不用时齐平不可见;也可设计附加配件。
查看依据(1 处)
u/ducmite
I would like to see couple MOLLE like attachment points in the bottom of the bag, so I could use couple straps for things like a heavy jacket, blanket, extra bag etc. When unused, they would be flush and not visible.定位到评论 ↓个人经历
ducmite 在客户现场工作时希望解放双手,会挂夹克;额外包可装运动鞋;底部MOLLE同色时几乎不可见,外侧可见织带只适合某些审美。
主要问题
00Anonymous 认为包有太多单一用途的空间。
查看依据(1 处)
个人经历
moksori 在热带潮湿国家通勤,指出背包肩带无衬垫勒肩、背部出汗、不能自立、笔记本隔层保护不足、缺乏收纳面板、无外部侧袋、不防水防污、太大笨重等问题;喜欢内置可拆卸防雨罩(U Elements 有),希望尺寸为个人物品大小。
查看依据(2 处)
u/moksori
Uncomfortable/unpadded straps that dig in to my shoulders - Sweaty back during commute in a tropical humid country - Doesn't stand up on its own, so it's difficult to put down near my desk. I need it to be stiff/hold its shape - Laptop compartment too unprotected. I would prefer false bottom/corner guards - Lack of organizers/admin panel. I find big empty compartments too unwieldy. I would prefer interior side pockets for small items, a strap/loop for attaching my keys, IDs, space for chargers/connectors/flash drives/pens - Lack of exterior expandable side pockets. I have a foldable umbrella and a regular sized water tumbler that I regularly need to be accessible. - Non-water/stain resistant materials - Too big and bulky. Size-wise, I would prefer personal item size for air travel.定位到评论 ↓u/moksori
Favorite feature I wish other bags had: built in/removable raincover. My beat up U Elements had one.定位到评论 ↓具体建议
ducmite 建议防雨罩可收纳但可拆卸,以便用后晾干。
查看依据(1 处)
个人经历
moksori 坚持可收纳且可拆卸的防雨罩,现有包内置,用小扣固定底部,可解开晾干再扣回;理想容量25-30L,希望有拉链扩展。
查看依据(2 处)
u/moksori
Won't compromise on: the stowable AND removable rain cover. The one I have now is built-in/included with the bag. It locks in at the bottom with a tiny clip, then when it rains and I need to dry it off, I can unclip it and just attach it back when it's dry.定位到评论 ↓具体建议
OJGThree 希望快速取放口袋(QAP)真正快速且不受主仓装载影响;认为拉链上的Aquaguard是没用的高级功能;希望Smart Alec顶部翻盖整合QAP。
查看依据(3 处)
u/OJGThree
Feature I wish more bags had: QAP that fulfills the "Q" part and doesn't get limited by how much is in the main compartment定位到评论 ↓u/OJGThree
Bag specific: would love if a QAP was incorporated into the top flap on the Smart Alec, just doesn't feel good trying to use the side pockets for that定位到评论 ↓具体建议
OJGThree 希望QAP在背着时也能取用,但放下时取用也重要;不需要大矩形盒子,只需能装手机、钱包、钥匙等过TSA前从口袋拿出的东西。
查看依据(1 处)
u/OJGThree
Ideally when worn, but not that much less important when set down....and I am not asking for a big rectangular box on the outside of the bag, just something that, yeah, can hold a phone, wallet, keys, anything that I want to take out of my pockets and put in the bag before going through TSA定位到评论 ↓个人经历
Jorge-I-Figueroa 是Evergoods粉丝,拥有多款包,认为CTB26装满时舒适性设计差。
查看依据(1 处)
u/Jorge-I-Figueroa
I'm a big fan of evergoods, love the ctb26, but boy, it is so poorly designed for comfort when packed.定位到评论 ↓个人经历
Jorge-I-Figueroa 在京都、伏见稻荷、金阁寺、岚山全天携带CTB26,装笔记本电脑等,背部被勒出印子,认为Evergoods背负系统不适合;MPL22也不够舒适。
查看依据(1 处)
u/Jorge-I-Figueroa
They look nice, ctb26 carries a ton, but I took mine all day, laptop and all in Kyoto, Fushimi inari, kinkaku ji, bought some sukajan , arashiyama and my back was marked, the evergoods harness is mot made for that, i also have a mpl22 and not even that is that comfortable (this one is great for throwing thing in quickly)定位到评论 ↓个人经历
ducmite 认为CTB26舒适性取决于背长,肩带收紧时很好,太松时底端搁下背部,重载可能勒入;见过有人拆背部结构板可能有帮助。
查看依据(1 处)
u/ducmite
I think it depends on how tall back user has. If I have my CTB26 straps tight it is great but I can tell when shoulder straps are too loose, the bottom end rests on my lower back and I feel with a heavy load it could really dig in and be uncomfortable. I've seen people mention that removing the structural sheet in the back would help.定位到评论 ↓
评论
本次保存的 19 条评论,非完整评论;不含点赞数查看原文
查看原文
查看原文
查看原文
查看原文
查看原文
查看原文
查看原文
查看原文
查看原文
查看原文
查看原文
查看原文
查看原文
查看原文
查看原文
查看原文
查看原文
查看原文